Tomato Pie

I always look forward to tasting REAL tomatoes each summer – the ones that come from the local gardens instead of the “plastic” tomatoes from the store. I love the variety of colors, sizes, and tastes! Coincidentally, I stumbled upon a tomato pie recipe on Camellia’s Cottage blog and I’ve decided to give it a try.

On Saturday morning, prompted by a reminder photo shared by a good friend (Art) on Facebook, I headed downtown Knoxville to the farmers’ market in search of tomatoes. I came home with much more than that, of course, but I did manage to get some really good looking tomatoes for my pie.

I am really bad about following recipes, so I made my own version of this decadent treat. I used Toufayan wraps as the base instead of a pie crust and I brushed them with olive oil.

I mixed Greek yogurt with Avocado salad dressing instead of using Mayo and sour cream. I added about a tablespoon of fresh purple onion and bell pepper, finely chopped to the mix. I also added extra herbs from my “garden” (I do not have a particularly green thumb but I manage to keep my container herbs alive throughout the season, even if I’ve been known to kill cacti…). I really love the Mexican tarragon and the Greek oregano – they seem to have a nicer flavor than the other varieties I tried – and, of course, I cannot skip the sweet basil.

Farmers' Market Tomatoes
Farmers’ Market Tomatoes
Greek Oregano
Mexican Tarragon
Sweet Basil
Tomato pie in the makings

For the cheese, I grated some sharp cheddar (since I found out that they add cellulose in the pre-shredded cheese, I prefer to grate my own). I really could have used a lot more but I’m trying (and failing, and trying again) to mind my weight and my husband’s high cholesterol (no fun). However, I did add prosciutto as a decadent touch and a hint of smokiness to balance the acid/tartness of the tomatoes.

I baked the pie for about 55 minutes, checking on it from time to time. My tomatoes gave a lot of juice, which would have probably been better handled by a regular pie crust. Although, I thought about trying another version and using polenta as the base.

Side note: for some reason, spellcheck wanted to replace “polenta” with “tadpole.” I don’t recommend it :-).

Although not as great as the original recipe, my version of Sister’s Tomato Pie was very tasty indeed. Many thanks to Camellia for sharing!

Happy eating!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.